About Me

Our Story
Jonathan Stewart’s journey in real estate began in 2004 when he started taking his real estate courses after a simple but meaningful conversation with Evelyn Miller, an experienced local Realtor®, after church. That same year, Jonathan joined Sutton Group - Sault Ste. Marie Realty.
Over the last 20 years, Jonathan has established himself as an honest, caring and productive real estate Broker and Team Leader in Northern Ontario, centred around Sault Ste. Marie.
In 2016, Anne Garofalo was hired to assist in further building and managing the growing real estate business. Anne serves today as our Listing and Transaction Manager, overseeing all things from contract to close.
In 2017, Shannon Vine joined the Stewart Team as our dedicated photographer, shooting photos, creating virtual tours and floor plans, flying our drone, and designing marketing ads.
In 2018, Jonathan’s wife Marney joined Jonathan in the real estate business as Co-Owner and Client Care Manager. Marney ensures that the quality of our client experience goes above and beyond typical buying and selling expectations.
That same year, Paul Mathewson, supported by his lovely wife Ruth, joined Stewart Team as our first ‘Senior’ Sales Partner, and we are very honoured to have him representing the Stewart Team in Sault Ste. Marie. Paul really likes helping people get where they want to go.
2018 saw other exciting changes as the Stewart Team joined Royal LePage Northern Advantage. “Going Above and Beyond” became our new slogan which reflects the service we have always strived to provide our clients - the best real estate experience possible!
Shortly after, Mary Stevenson became our stager, consulting with and helping clients to prepare their homes for photos and virtual tours.
Theo Straatsma joined the Team as a new agent in Spring 2021, and provides dedicated service to his Buyer and Seller clients in the area from St. Joseph Island to Blind River. Theo and his wife Lisa live and work on Big Basswood Lake east of Thessalon.
Jeff Pullan is the friendly face of our St. Joseph Island office which opened in 2022 in Richards Landing, across from the Island Market. Jeff serves as Client Service Manager, ensuring our new and past clients are well taken care of.
Madeline Gabor works with Mary to get our client homes photo ready, and is also studying to obtain her real estate license.
Cody Stubbe joined the Stewart Team in 2023, after a successful career in Volkswagen sales, and continues to put clients first in a caring and professional manner. Cody and his wife Stephanie live on St. Joseph Island, and Cody serves the North Shore and Soo areas.
Brian Whitley, a long-time family friend and retired teacher and engineer, got his real estate license in 2024 and joined the Stewart Team. He is kind, professional, and caring. We are happy to have him on the Team, and he and his wife Heather as fellow Islanders.
From the start, our business has succeeded only because of two things: God’s never-ending kindness and generosity; and the kind recommendations and referrals of our clients and customers over the years. For both of these we can only say “Thank You” to our clients and to our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.
That’s our story. And we look forward to hearing yours!